Two buyers can order the same number of clicks, at the same tier, in the same week, and get results that look like they came from different planets. The reason is solo ad traffic quality, and it is not a single dial. Traffic sorts into three levels: low intent, medium intent and high intent.
Once you can see those three levels, most of the confusion in this business evaporates, including why the cheapest clicks are the cheapest.
A click is a record that somebody pressed a link. That record says nothing about why.
Two people click the same link. One read the email, recognised their own problem in it, and went looking for the answer. The other was skimming and their thumb moved. Same click on any report ever built. Completely different value to you.
That gap is what intent describes, and it is decided before the click ever reaches your page.
Low intent is a click with no real desire behind it.
The person was not looking for what you sell. They were not moved by the email. Something else got them to click: habit, curiosity, a nudge, or a reward for clicking that had nothing to do with your offer.
You can recognise low intent by its behaviour after the click. It produces weak opt ins, and the ones that do opt in never open anything again. You end up with subscribers on paper and silence in practice.
Low intent is also why cheap clicks are cheap. It is not a discount on the same product. It is a different product with the same name, which is the whole argument in why $0.30 clicks cost you more.
Medium intent is a real person with some genuine interest who is not actively hunting for a solution today.
They read the email, something in it caught them, and they wanted a closer look. That is a legitimate click. It is just not urgent.
Medium intent opts in at a decent rate and then waits. These people become buyers, but the persuasion happens in your follow up rather than on click day. If your sequence is thin, medium intent looks like wasted money. If your sequence is good, it is the bulk of a healthy list.
This is exactly why I say mail twice a day for the first 30 days. Medium intent is a numbers game played over weeks, and you only win it if you are still showing up.
High intent is somebody who read the email, recognised the problem as theirs, and clicked because they wanted the answer now.
They opt in. They open the next email. They reply. They are the people Seth Johnson was describing when he said the subscribers I send him are actually openers.
Seth's results are his own. Your results depend on your offer, your page, and your follow up.
High intent is the goal, and you do not get it by paying more. You get it by qualifying the reader before the click.
Here is the part most buyers never consider: intent is largely manufactured by the email.
An email written to maximise clicks will maximise clicks. Vague curiosity, a mystery link, a promise of something free and unspecified. Lots of clicks, almost all of them low intent, and the click count looks fantastic on a report.
An email written to qualify says who this is for and what it is about, which means some readers decide it is not for them and do not click. You get fewer clicks from the same send, and the clicks you get came from people who already put their hand up.
That is why I write the email for every single order myself, and have for 12 years. The ad is not a formality. The ad is where intent is decided, and handing that job to a template or to whoever is cheapest is how buyers end up with a list that will not open. My process is in how I write every solo ad I send.
Your page has to hold up its end too. If the ad qualifies hard and then the page changes the subject, the intent you paid for evaporates on arrival.
You cannot read intent off a click report. No tracker reports motivation. What you can do is watch behaviour, in this order:
Opt in rate, day one. Low intent shows up as an opt in rate that is poor despite a page that has worked before. If the page is new, this tells you less, because the page could be the problem.
Opens in the first week. This is the real tell. High and medium intent open. Low intent opts in and vanishes. If you have a list of subscribers where almost nobody opens anything, intent was low and no subject line will fix it.
Replies. Nothing fakes a reply. Even a handful means real people are on the other end.
Sales across 30 days. The end of the story. Medium intent buys late, low intent never buys.
Run it on at least 500 clicks, which is the minimum for viable data, and use your own tracking alongside your autoresponder so the numbers are yours. How to track solo ad clicks walks through that.
Stop shopping on price per click. Price per click prices the record, not the person.
Ask instead: who writes the email, what does it say, and does it qualify or does it just provoke a click. That question separates the three levels far more reliably than any rate card. It is also the core of how to choose a solo ads vendor.
Then measure your cost per subscriber and what that batch of subscribers does over 30 days, because those numbers include intent whether you can see it directly or not.
Order 500 clicks and watch how many of them open the next email.
Your first solo ad campaign, start to finish. What to build before you spend anything, what to order, what to track, and how to judge the results after 30 days without lying to yourself.
October 8, 2026 · 4 min read
Cost per click is the number everybody shops on and the one that tells you the least. Here is how to work out cost per subscriber, earnings per click, and the 30 day value of a lead, with a worked example at 500 clicks.
October 7, 2026 · 4 min read
A solo ad squeeze page has exactly one job: trade a promise for an email address. Here is how to build one that does that job, from the headline to the button, and what to rip off the page before you send traffic.
October 5, 2026 · 4 min read